Recent News

McGee on Necessitation and Conditional Proof

19 August 2015

I’ve been taking great pleasure in reading Ole Hjortland and Colin Caret’s recent edited collection of papers from the long running Arche ‘Foundations of Logical Consequence’ project. So far I’ve greatly enjoyed every paper in the collection. What I want to point out here is a rather curious passage in Van McGee’s contribution “The Categoricity of Logic”. After claiming that the meanings of the sentential-connectives are given by their natural deduction rules McGee goes on to make the following, rather curious, comment.

Read More →


The Barcan Formula, Necessary Existence and the Actuality Operator

9 April 2015

One of the problems which those of us who believe that there are things which exist contingently (Contingentists to use Timothy Williamson’s terminology) usually have with the Barcan Formula (=$\Diamond\exists x A \supset \exists x\Diamond A$) is that it somehow entails that everything which exists exists necessarily. Usually this is demonstrated by appealing to the Converse Barcan Formula as well, which by itself already makes trouble for the contingentist. This might lead one to suspect that the Barcan Formula is somehow ‘safe’ so long as it doesn’t bring the Converse Barcan Formula with it.

Read More →


Urn Logic, Quantification and Modal Logic

13 March 2015

One of the great pleasures of doing logic is finding problems in one area which can be solved using the techniques and insights from another. What I want to briefly mention here is a neat example of this involving an interesting approach to quantificational logic due to Veikko Rantala called ‘Urn Logic’. The core idea behind urn logic’s semantics for the quantifiers is that the objects which the quantifiers range over can vary over the course of the evaluation of a formula, depending on which objects are selected from the domain by earlier quantifiers. Veikko’s original semantics for this is in the style of Hintikka’s game theoretic semantics, and I’ve proposed a more standard version of the semantics in my ‘A Sequent Calculus for Urn Logic’. What I’m interested in here, though, is a ‘classical’ semantics for Urn Logic proposed by Max Cresswell, and how a question he asks about the expressivity of this semantics can be answered using a very familiar construction from modal logic.

Read More →


Introductions

27 February 2015

Hello! Welcome to this, the website of Rohan French, Australian philosohical logician at large in Europe. I’ve been meaning to put this site together for some time, and was recently inspired by the redesign of Greg Restall’s wonderful consequently.org, and how pleasant (for a tinkerer who briefly worked as a web developer) Hugo was to use.

Read More →


News Archive

2015

McGee on Necessitation and Conditional Proof // The Barcan Formula, Necessary Existence and the Actuality Operator // Urn Logic, Quantification and Modal Logic // Introductions //